This article outlines four techniques of Male to Female Sex Reassignment Surgeries (SRS), what each surgery entails (surgical plan), and the advantages and disadvantages of each procedure.
Penile Inversion Vaginoplasty
Utilizes skin from the outside of the penis to create the lining of the neovagina. The clitoris is built from the sensitive skin at the tip of the penis. Finally, scrotal skin is used to construct the labia majora.
Scrotal Skin Grafting Vaginoplasty
Utilizes a skin graft from the scrotum to construct the labia, urethra, vestibule, clitoris, and clitoral hood. Due to the fact that the vagina is created from existing genitalia, this technique allows for nerves to remain intact, allowing for the functionality and sensitivity of a natal vagina.
Sigmoid Colon Vaginoplasty
A graft of the patient’s colon is used to create the vaginal wall and the scrotal tissue is used to create labia majora, labia minora, and vaginal opening. Because the vagina is grafted from the colon, it is self lubricating. This technique is currently the most widely-chosen SRS surgery.
Peritoneal Pull-through Vaginoplasty
The peritoneum, the moist inner lining of the abdominal wall, is pulled down between the rectum and prostate, to create the vaginal lining and vaginal reconstruction. The remainder of the vaginoplasty procedures (labiaplasty, clitoroplasty, penectomy, orchiectomy, partial urethrectomy, and other associated procedures) are created from a scrotal skin graft, similar to that of the penile inversion technique. Type of SRS Surgery
Penile Inversion Vaginoplasty
Penile Inversion Vaginoplasty is a male-to-female gender reassignment technique, where the penile skin is inverted to create a vagina. Compared to the other methods, penile skin inversion is relatively simple and usually takes approximately 4 hours to complete.
In the penile inversion technique, skin from the outside of the penis is used for the lining of the neovagina. The clitoris is built from the sensitive skin at the tip of the penis. Finally, scrotal skin is used to construct the labia majora.
The penile inversion technique can provide patients with a sexually functional and aesthetically pleasing neovagina with excellent sensation but without the higher risk of complications of the more invasive procedures, such as sigmoid colon vaginoplasty. However, because of the shallow depth of the neovagina, the procedure is best suited for patients who do not wish to have vaginal intercourse after surgery.
Scrotal Skin Grafting Vaginoplasty
The scrotal skin graft and flap method is a common method and recommended for many SRS patients. Under this technique, skin graft and preputial flap are used to construct a neovagina and its main parts including clitoral hood, clitoris, vestibule, urethra, and labia. The surgery usually lasts 6-7 hours.
With this technique, the neovagina is constructed from different parts of the existing genitalia. With most of its nerves and vessels remaining intact, the newly constructed neovagina is functional and has erogenous sensitivity. Furthermore, due to the delicate selection of the material used, the neovagina will be very similar to that of a cisgender woman in terms of beauty, color, shape, arrangement, and size.
Type of SRS Surgery
Sigmoid Graft Vaginoplasty
Sigmoid colon vaginoplasty is a specialized SRS technique that transforms a penis and scrotum into a functional and aesthetically pleasing neovagina. By adding the patient’s colon graft inside the vaginal wall, the preputial flap and scrotal skin can be effectively utilized to form an aesthetically pleasing and functional labia minora, labia majora and vaginal opening while the sufficient depth is still achieved by a colon graft. A section of colon is grafted, resulting vagina with normal discharge.
Advantages:
- Prevents unnatural appearance of red colon mucosa that arises in other colon vaginoplasty SRS
- Many results of other surgeons’ sigmoid vaginoplasty show a visibly red color of the colon mucosa at the lower part of the vaginal opening. However, this is not found in the vagina of a natal female. Dr. Theerapong’s technique corrects this outcome by utilizing the posterior flap on the sides of the vaginal opening. This conceals the junction between colon and skin flap, and makes the red color not visible at the lower part of the vaginal opening.
- Widening neovaginal opening to accommodate smoother intercourse and dilation
- One of the striking advantages of the sigmoid colon vaginoplasty procedure is that this design can create extended labia minora and wider opening of neovagina, which results in more comfortable sexual intercourse and dilation. Therefore, patients undergoing this technique can have pleasurable intercourse and fewer difficulties with dilation. The average depth of a vagina constructed by colon vaginoplasty is 7 inches.
Disadvantages:
- Visible incisional scar on the bikini line.
- Patients will need to have bowel preparation and can have only liquid food before and after the operation.
- Longer recovery period compared to other SRS methods.
Type of SRS Surgery
Peritoneal Pull-through Vaginoplasty
Peritoneal Pull-Through Vaginoplasty, or Peritoneal Vaginoplasty, is a newer male to female surgery procedure that’s based on a gynecological procedure called the Davydov Procedure.
Peritoneal Pull Through Procedure is an abdominal approach to obtain peritoneum and develop Denonvilliers fascia between the rectum and prostate to create a space for the neo-vagina or vaginal reconstruction.
Risks include all the risks involved in a penile inversion technique if being done concurrently, as well as: stricture, stenosis, graft failure, lack of lubrication, and risks of abdominal procedure of damage to bowel, bladder, prostate, muscles, nerves, and vessels. Another risk is the lack of literature and long-term data on this procedure.
Which SRS Surgery/Technique is right for YOU?
The suitable surgical method varies from person to person depending on their specific needs and preferences. To determine which surgical method is the most suitable for their sex reassignment surgery, patients should consider the following factors:
- Depth of the vagina they wish to have and its functionality implications.
- Desired characteristics of their labia majora, how large and how firm labia majora would they prefer to have?
- Incisional scar on labia majora and preferences as to whether the scar is on the inner or the outer side of labia majora.
- Desired characteristics of their labia minora (size and appearance)
- Size of clitorisPatients should think carefully about these factors before consulting with doctors. Preference of these factors can be communicated to the doctor during consultation so that the doctors can provide recommendations and design the best surgical plan for patients.
Type of SRS Surgery